Tim MoriartyDr. Sam Sheppard
Airen DeLaMaterMarilyn Sheppard
Collin WareDetective Schottke
Thomas LombardoDetective Garreau
Brendan ReardonF. Lee Bailey
Cameron DelGrossoRichard Eberling (Younger)
Robert BlakeRichard Eberling (Older)
David ConklinDr. Paul Kirk
Bradley AndersonStephen Sheppard
Mike SuttonCoroner Gerber
Raymond KellyChief Easton
Cain PerryDetective Grabowski
Jason TateRichard Sheppard Jr
Diodato GrisiRichard Sheppard Sr
Joel HaberliJudge Blythin
Quinn KronenCorrigan
Kathryn HahnerEthel Sheppard
Paul SaltzbergProsecutor Parrino
Chase AndersonChip Sheppard
Lawrence DerxLawrence Martin
Allen EnlowJohn Mahon Prosecuting Attorney
Alisha SpielmannNancy Ahern
Isabel LodgeBerättare
Elise RovinskyBerättare
