Janet MontgomeryMary Sibley
Shane WestJohn Alden
Seth GabelCotton Mather
Ashley MadekweTituba
Tamzin MerchantAnne Hale
Elise EberleMercy Lewis
Joe DoyleBaron Sebastian Marburg
Oliver Bell
Iddo GoldbergIsaac Walton
Samuel RoukinThe Sentinel
Jeremy CrutchleyHathorne
Jonathan CoyneTreasurer Putnam
Meagan FayMrs. Stoughton
Robert PicardoMr. Stoughton
Emily SkeggsBilly
Ashlyn PearceAlice
Timothy FallFrench Commander
Clint JamesTowering Bird Dick Man
Nadine LewingtonRebecca Nurse
Morgana ShawEssex Elder
Gregory NyeSelectman
Jeremy SummersNight Watchman